NBA – Now & Then… Do they matchup?
From special BHR contributing writer Alex Tsironis
On the heels of the Dream Team documentary, I got to thinking about how todays players would compare to the players I watched growing up. Of course, none of these players have an exact match, and the manner in which I’ll be comparing these guys won’t be the same across the board…but I’ll give it a shot.
We’ll start with some of the Western Conference All-Stars:
Kevin Durant:
Larry Bird (’84-’88). Bird and Durant are about the same size and they can both score from anywhere on the court. Bird averaged more rebounds and more assists, and Durant has him beat on athleticism, but they are very similar players.
Blake Griffin:
Shawn Kemp (’92-’99): Both of these guys can jump out of the gym. Kemp, along with Gary Payton, was able to lead the Sonics to the NBA Finals. Griffin is the better scorer/rebounder, but they play a very similar style, and now Griffin has a point guard of his own.
Kobe Bryant:
Michael Jordan: This comparison has been made since Kobe started winning championships, but it’s is as close as we will ever get to MJ. Killer instinct, willingness to take over, deadly when they need to be. Very similar in the way they play.
Chris Paul:
Isiah Thomas (’83-’87): Similar in size, toughness, and production. A lot of people don’t realize that in this 4 year span, Thomas averaged over 20 ppg and just under 12 apg. Thomas was a champion, and Paul has about 5 good years left to prove that he can be one too.
Dirk Nowitzki:
Chris Mullin (’88-’93): It is very difficult to compare Nowitzki to any one player. He is 3 inches taller than Larry Bird and gets his shot off over people rather than with a quick release. I would liken him to a much taller version of Chris Mullin, who was a good shooter and solid rebounder, while lacking a major defensive presence.
Tony Parker:
Kevin Johnson (’88-’92): Tony Parker is a quick, smart, aggressive point guard that can beat you many different ways. Parker is the better shooter, but KJ was the faster of the two. Between ’88-’92, Johmson average over 20 ppg and almost 11 apg. After this years playoffs, Parker is once again being talked about as possibly the best point guard in the NBA.
Kevin Love:
Karl Malone: Kevin Love was a great rebounder as soon as he came into the league and his scoring has caught up. Averaging 26 and 13 in his 4th year, Love has become one of the most effective players in the game. Malone was able to sustain that over the course of his 19 year career. Love has the edge when it comes to the boards, and Malone was the better scorer.
Moving on to some of the Eastern Conference All-Stars:
Carmelo Anthony:
Grant Hill (’94-’00): Nearly identical in size, Hill was one of the games best players at the turn of the century. It’s very easy to forget exactly how good Hill was at this point in time, but their approach to the game is very similar. Injuries forced Hill into becoming a role player, while Melo has yet to meet a shot he doesn’t like. Anthony may be the better rebounder, but Hill was very well-rounded.
LeBron James:
Charles Barkley: While many compare LBJ to Magic, the way he attacks the basket and can score from almost anywhere on the court, is more similar to Sir Charles. James is clearly the superior passer, while Barkley beats him out when it comes to rebounds. Up until this year, they were the best two players to never win a championship.
Derrick Rose:
Allen Iverson: D-Rose is unmatched when it comes to his athleticism. AI was a better shooter early on, and they both attack the basket without mercy. Rose may be a better distributor, but Iverson was able to double the amount of steals Rose has had in his first few seasons. Both of them have the ability to turn a team completely around.
Dwyane Wade:
Clyde Drexler: Drexler was the better outside shooter and rebounder (mainly because of his size), but both of these guys could get to the basket at will. Not many people realize how quick Drexler was in his prime, as he could guard anyone from a point guard to a power forward. Wade is smaller, but has the toughness to guard a 1, 2, or 3. Both were clutch for their teams.
Rajon Rondo:
Gary Payton: Rondo and Payton both excel on the defensive end of the floor. Payton developed into a solid scorer, and Rondo has shown that he can do he same at times. Rajon has been blessed with a great supporting cast, and it will be interesting to see how he develops as the Celtics become his team.
Deron Williams:
Tim Hardaway: Hardaway was an amazing ball handler that could pull up from anywhere. Williams is the same. Deron is a better finisher at the basket, while Hardaway had one of the deadliest crossover dribbles. Interested to see where Deron Williams next stop will be.
All in all, it’s impossible to compare someone to just one other player. There are aspects of each players game that won’t matchup with anothers. We are also in a different time, where athleticism is through the roof and 7 footers are stroking three pointers the same way a 2-guard does. I feel good with my comparisons, do you agree?
Category: Home
















The Kobe and MJ comparison is the best one
Deron Williams is a STUD though, best PG in NBA..
Out of all theses players I dont feel as though the younginZ get the nod nowhere. Bird : Pure 4th quarter MAN, uncomprehensible will to ge that ball made up for athleticism and his savyness to know when to hold a player when no one is looking. Kemp: Better face up J early on, better Post up early on, same tenacity above the rim. Jordan: NO COMPARISON >>>> DEFENSE and true WILL Isiah: That boy was a leader, took over games consistently, and was a TRUE leader. With the exception of Mello and rose who are equals to there opponents, and Wade and Rondo are not good comparisons I feel the Ol skool is rather apparent to get the NOD. The difference is the ease that the benjamins are obtained to the younginZ and the lack of consistent determintation to improve and to learn how to play DEFENSE. Pleae dont compare MJ to Mamba-Head again. :)
Barkley was a 6'4 big man and LBJ is a 6'8 everything. He is Magic with a mean streak
Almost impossible to compare guys like Wade and Rose to anyone from the 80's and 90's because they are so damn athletic. Never thought of Iverson...pretty good
Kobe will never be Jordan! Fly like an eagle ..Space jam MF's
It's tough to compare to just one guy, but this is pretty good.
Never thought about how similar Bird and Durant were. Durant is the modern day Larry Bird
I first would like to say that the article is well written. I enjoy reading all your opinions especially the comparison between Kobe and MJ. I think that is spot on. I am glad that you did not compare Lebron to MJ, because we won't know how that turns out for at least another 4 to 5 years and that is already over-hyped. Lebron to Barkley is a stretch as well, since I see Barkley as more of an inside power type guy than an all-around player like Lebron, but we could argue for days. Since this is a DC grown site, how about some Wizards comparisons.
My brother used to love Shawn Kemp bc of how he used to dunk on everyone...and now he loves Blake Griffin. Ditto with the Kobe/MJ comparisons
Pretty good comparisons...especially if they are to just one guy.
Just so everyone knows...I wasn't trying to compare one guy to a mix of two. Just one individual comparison.